from the pass —
Menu photos
A few dishes from the current card — tap any shot to view larger.
1 / 10
Discover the New York Pizzeria menu featuring classic NYC-style pizzas, specialty wings, hot subs, and tasty sides in Cato, NY. Fresh ingredients, crispy crusts, and rave local reviews make it a must-visit! Call +1 315-626-6662 for orders.
New York Pizzeria in Cato, NY, delivers an authentic slice of classic New York-style pizza right in the heart of this small town. The menu is rich with options that satisfy both casual diners and devoted pizza lovers alike. Their pizzas feature a golden, crispy crust with a tender, chewy center, layered with tangy, savory sauce and fresh, generous toppings. Beyond pizza, the variety extends to hearty wraps like Buffalo Chicken and Philly Steak, perfect for a flavorful meal on the go.
Complementing the mains are crispy sides including chicken tenders, mozzarella sticks, and loaded fries that create a well-rounded dining experience. Pasta lovers will enjoy comforting plates like Chicken Parmesan, Lasagna, and Fettuccini Alfredo, each prepared with quality ingredients. The rave customer reviews praise both the outstanding food and warm, friendly service, confirming New York Pizzeria as a hidden gem where taste and authenticity come together flawlessly.
A few dishes from the current card — tap any shot to view larger.
I don't think the locals appreciate how good they got it! For someone from the Midwest, this is a hidden treasure, Just great, classic New York style pizzeria pizza, with a fantastic authentic small town atmosphere and service. The wings are also a great add-on to complete the experience. It's seriously in the middle of no where, but it you're close it's worth a visit.
Opening hours, the full address and the best way to get there are all on the restaurant page. Booking policies differ from place to place — so call ahead, or simply walk in.